One customer's review · Edward J. Henry & Sons Auto Body Shop · Wilmington, DE

Quoted a week. Kept for two months.

A blue Honda CR-V with a crying ;_; face on its windshield
Fig. 1. My CR-V around week six, wondering if anyone's coming back for it. (Dramatization.)

I brought my car in with a damaged frame and was told about a week. Two months later I'd sat through supplement after supplement, lost my point of contact to a surprise resignation, called nearly every week just to confirm my car still existed, and then, on pickup day, learned it was being held until my insurer coughed up another $1,200.

How a one-week job takes two months

Yellow = things the shop told me, as best I remember them. I couldn't make these up if I tried.

  1. Week 0

    The innocent beginning

    My door met a curb I genuinely could not see. I brought the car in, and Ryan, who did my estimate, said the frame was damaged and it'd be a tough repair. His quote: about a week. Go through insurance, he said. Sure. Sounds easy.

  2. Week 1

    Nobody had touched the claim

    One week in, I found out my claim hadn't moved at all until I called about it, thanks to some miscommunication between Ryan and my insurer. Ryan's take: my insurer wasn't good at doing the claims. Noted.

    Also, surprise: the repair was going to cost more than they thought, so they needed a supplement from my insurer. Remember that word. It comes back. A lot.

  3. Weeks 1–3

    The invisible adjuster

    I called my insurer to make sure they sent an adjuster out. Then I called Ryan, who told me no adjuster had been there. My insurer, meanwhile, had proof that one had. So either the adjuster was a ghost, or someone at the shop missed them.

  4. Week 3

    Good news, bad news

    Good news: about three weeks in, my car was finally being worked on.

    Bad news: the next time I called, I found out Ryan didn't work there anymore. Nobody told me. Apparently he just quit, no notice. My car's new guardians were Tamara and Sam.

  5. Weeks 4–7

    I become their most loyal caller

    Tamara said she'd inform me of updates. What actually happened: I called nearly every week to ask how my own car was doing. One update, total, came my way before I called to complain that nobody was telling me anything.

  6. Week 7

    Supplement: the sequel

    Seven weeks in, they needed another supplement. The reason? Ryan hadn't done a good job estimating the claim. Ryan, who quit. Ryan, who wasn't around to defend himself. Blaming the guy who left is a bold strategy, and it did not make me feel better.

    Then came the explanations, roughly in this order. The repair was complex. They needed a part they didn't have. They were waiting on parts they hadn't known they needed. And my personal favorite: they didn't know what they didn't know.

    I'm not a mechanic. I tried to give them the benefit of the doubt. But the lack of confidence, the mixed messages and the nonstop hedging about delays felt unprofessional.

  7. Week 8

    Your car is ready. You can't have it.

    About two months and a frankly ridiculous number of phone calls later, my car was done. Great! Except on the day it was finished, I was told it would not be released to me until my insurer paid for the supplement. What supplement? There couldn't possibly be another supplement. (There was.)

    Sam explained that this was my insurer's fault for not paying the extra cost, and that if they gave me my own car back they'd “take the hit” if insurance didn't pay. I asked how their lack of planning had become my problem. Their answer: call your insurer.

    So I called my insurer. They had paid every claim and two adjustments. I called Sam back and asked whether this new adjustment had been made that same day. He said yes, and that blaming my insurer had been a “miscommunication”. Interesting word for saying one thing and then the opposite.

    Next instruction: call the adjuster responsible for approving a $1,200 calibration. And whose fault was this one? Ryan's estimate. For someone who hadn't worked there in weeks, Ryan still had an amazing amount of influence over my car.

    Somewhere around here I started to feel like the shop was wringing every penny it could out of my insurer, and my car was the hostage.

    I've lost count of the miscommunications. I would just like my car back, please.

The excuse ledger

Everything the shop told me, in order, next to what I actually found out.

WhenThe shop saidMeanwhile, in reality
Week 1 My insurer isn't good at doing claims. My claim only moved once I called. So who's bad at claims?
Week 1 The repair costs more than we thought. It needs a supplement. Supplement #1. Not the last.
Weeks 1–3 No adjuster has been here. My insurer had proof one had.
Week 7 We need another supplement. Ryan's estimate was poor. Ryan had already quit.
Week 7 The repair is complex. We need parts we didn't know we needed. We don't know what we don't know. Fair. Neither did I. More delays.
Week 8 We can't release the car until your insurer pays. It's your insurer's fault. My insurer had paid every claim and two adjustments.
Week 8 Blaming your insurer was a “miscommunication.” The adjustment had been made that same day.
Week 8 Call the adjuster to approve a $1,200 calibration. It's Ryan's fault. Ryan hadn't worked there for weeks. Still his fault, apparently.

Turns out it's not just me

From the shop's public Google reviews, owner replies included, because honestly the replies are part of the experience. Names withheld. Quotes are as posted; “…” means the review was cut off. Ages as shown on Google in November 2026.

Deadlines

My caseQuoted a week, took about eight. Rookie numbers next to this one.

Google review · edited about a month ago

I dropped my vehicle off on January 20 and was told repairs would take one to two months. Instead, they kept it for about seven months, repeatedly missed deadlines, and made me feel like I was getting the runaround. …

Owner response · about a month ago

Hi [reviewer]. I am sorry you aren't satisfied.

This was a massive $50,000 repair. It was dropped off at the peak of our business last winter. Yes, the repairs took forever. We want your vehicle (and all vehicles) back in our customers' hands as quickly as possible, repaired correctly. We missed the mark on yours. We have had multiple conversations about the remaining concerns you have. We are not done until you are completely satisfied.

We have spoken about the rental bill you have. As soon as you give us a copy, we will cut you a check, as mentioned to you before.

Reach out to us anytime. Regards- Zach Dillard

Surprise costs

My caseA $1,200 calibration that showed up on pickup day, with my car held until it was approved.

Google review · 3 years ago

Update: Of course you would say that and try to demean a customer’s concern as nonsense. I said it is the PRINCIPLE….had you pointed out the fee at drop off with the same vigor as you did at pick up, I would get to choose to take my …

Owner response · 3 years ago

Hello [reviewer]. We are very clear about the credit card surcharge upfront. That is why we have people initial the agreement stating there is a 3.5% surcharge. You even admit to signing it. I'm sorry to hear this fee upset you.

I'm glad your car looks good. That is what you came here for. A 1-star Google rating over $35 on your $1000 deductible is nonsense. If you want to address this further please give us a call.

Come back in and we will refund your 3.5% if that is your only concern. Hopefully, we will see you soon. Regards.

Radio silence

My caseI called nearly every week, and nobody mentioned my contact had quit. This person had it worse.

Google review · 3 months ago

Took my car there for insurance estimate. Told me that if totaled, they woul let me know so i could get my stuff out. Instead they released it without my knowledge. Had to drive 2hrs each way to get my stuff back from the scrap yard. Couldnt even tell me where it was taken to.

Owner response · 3 months ago

Hello [reviewer]. We are very sorry this happened. If we can make it up to you somehow, we will. Fuel reimbursement and tolls are completely reasonable. Please reach out if that helps.

Paint job

NoteOlder review, included for the record. I can't speak to the paint yet. I'd have to get my car back first.

Google review · 8 years ago

Painting on my rear door looks as if a child painted my door.

Owner response · 7 years ago

Hello [reviewer]. I am sorry you feel this way about the paint work. I realize it has been over a year since your car was repaired but if you feel like we should address something please stop in :)

So, would I recommend them?

Two months of runaround. I project-managed my own repair, chased every update myself, and got to meet a rotating cast of people to blame: my insurer, the guy who quit, my insurer again, the guy who quit again.

Do not patronize this place.